Finding motivated sellers is a numbers game. You're going to hear a lot of nos before you get a yes, which means you need volume. But volume alone isn't enough. Blasting generic messages to massive lists produces mediocre results.
The investors who consistently close deals understand that lead generation has two parts: building the right list and marketing to that list effectively. The first part is about filtering for sellers with genuine motivation signals, whether that's financial distress like pre-foreclosure or tax liens, life changes like divorce or inheritance, or property burden like vacancy or code violations. The second is about matching your outreach to their specific situation.
"This isn't just a property. There's an owner behind that property who's living a real life, dealing with real situations," says Melissa Stockton, Director of Marketing at PropertyReach, who has spent more than a decade helping investors grow their businesses through lead generation and marketing automation. "You want to know how to reach them, how to speak to them."
Here's how experienced investors find motivated sellers at scale.
If you're looking to scale beyond a handful of deals per year, a data platform is the foundation. Driving for dollars and courthouse research can surface leads, but neither approach lets you build large, targeted lists efficiently.
"If you're really looking to scale a business and get rid of your 9-to-5, the best way is to find a source where you can pull a large lead list," Stockton says.
What separates useful platforms from mediocre ones is data depth and accuracy. Look for comprehensive coverage of distress signals (pre-foreclosure, tax delinquency, bankruptcy, liens), property characteristics, and verified contact information including LLC and trust ownership. The best platforms offer more than a hundred useful filters to target by motivation, location, equity, property type, and more. Stale data wastes time and money.
The real leverage comes from segmentation and stacking.
Rather than pulling one generic "motivated seller" list, segment into cohort-specific lists: pre-foreclosure owners, absentee landlords, high-equity seniors. That way, you can tailor your messaging to each group's situation.
Properties that appear on multiple lists signal even stronger motivation. List stacking, or filtering for properties that match multiple motivation signals, is how experienced investors move from volume-based outreach to precision targeting. Instead of calling 1,000 random leads, you're calling 200 leads that each show three or four indicators of motivation.
This is also where AI-driven lead scoring creates leverage. Algorithms can analyze patterns across billions of data points, including ownership history, financial indicators, property characteristics, market trends. For example, PropertyReach's PropPulse AI scores properties based on predicted likelihood to sell within 90 days, letting investors prioritize outreach toward the highest-probability opportunities first.
Ready to stop guessing which leads to call first? Start your 7-day PropertyReach trial for just $7.
Direct mail remains one of the most reliable outreach channels, generating 34% ROI for prospects lists. Response rates are low, which is exactly why list quality and segmentation matter so much.
The mistake Stockton sees repeatedly: treating direct mail as a one-size-fits-all broadcast.
"Sending every lead the same direct mail piece is not going to be as effective as if you really tailor that messaging to their particular situation and pain points," she says.
A pre-foreclosure owner facing a 90-day timeline responds to messaging about protecting their credit and avoiding foreclosure's long-term consequences. An absentee landlord tired of managing a property from 1,000 miles away responds to messaging about convenience and certainty. Same channel, completely different approach.
Consistency matters too. A single campaign rarely produces results. Investors who treat direct mail as an ongoing system rather than a one-time experiment see compounding returns over time.
Cold calling and text outreach live or die by list quality, the same principle that applies to direct mail. But these channels add another variable: having sensitive conversations.
"A lot of times, especially when people are in these distress situations, they are going to be emotionally vulnerable. They're going to be nervous. They're going to be skeptical," Stockton says. "You need to be careful in how you approach them."
Come prepared. Before picking up the phone, know the property details, ownership history, and any distress signals that landed them on your list. That context shapes how you open the conversation and what solutions you can offer.
Skip tracing accuracy matters here more than anywhere else. Bad phone numbers waste calling hours. Reaching the LLC's registered agent instead of the actual decision-maker wastes even more. Platforms that verify contact data and identify beneficial owners behind entities give you a significant advantage.
Digital channels work differently than outbound methods. Instead of you reaching out to sellers, you're positioning yourself to be found when they're ready to act.
Paid advertising on Google and Facebook lets you target people actively searching for solutions or matching demographic profiles associated with motivation. The key is specificity. Generic "we buy houses" ads compete with every other investor in your market. Ads that speak to specific situations like facing foreclosure, inherited a property, or relocating for work cut through the noise.
Stockton suggests an advanced approach. "Instead of running ads and relying on the algorithms to find the right people, you can download lead lists and upload them to Google ads and Facebook ads so that you have these lookalike lists, giving those platforms a little bit more information about the type of homeowner that you're looking for."
Organic social media is slower but costs nothing. Stockton calls it "very underutilized" and recommends focusing on storytelling and sharing examples of sellers you've helped and situations you've resolved. The algorithm surfaces relevant content to non-followers, which means your reach isn't limited to your existing network.
The traditional approach to driving for dollars is simple. Cruise neighborhoods looking for signs of distress or vacancy. Overgrown lawns, boarded windows, piled-up mail, and deferred maintenance all signal potential motivation. Today, there are nearly 15 million vacant homes in the U.S., which translates to millions of potentially motivated sellers nationwide.
The problem is efficiency. Without preparation, you're spending hours in areas that may have nothing for you.
"You can get in your car, drive around a neighborhood, look for properties that are run down or maybe vacant, but it's going to be a lot more efficient to pull a list ahead of time so that you know exactly where you're going," Stockton says. "You're avoiding neighborhoods that are not going to have the homes that you're looking for."
With a filtered list as your roadmap, driving for dollars becomes a verification and intel-gathering exercise rather than a cold search. You already know which properties match your criteria. Now you're confirming their condition, noting details that don't appear in data, and identifying the best approach for outreach.
A homeowner whose listing expired or was withdrawn has already demonstrated intent to sell. Something went wrong (pricing, condition, timing, agent fit) but the underlying motivation likely remains.
These sellers have experienced the traditional process and came away frustrated. Your pitch should acknowledge that reality. You're offering a different path, not the same one that already failed them.
Access expired listing data through an agent relationship or a platform that syndicates MLS records. Focus on recent expirations, ideally within the past 30 to 60 days, before the seller either relists or mentally moves on.
FSBO listings follow similar logic. Owners who attempt to sell without an agent often underestimate the difficulty. FSBO sales take longer and sell for around 15% less than agent-assisted sales. After weeks or months of showings that go nowhere, many FSBO sellers become motivated to consider alternatives they wouldn't have entertained initially.
Referrals require no marketing spend and often arrive pre-qualified, but they depend entirely on relationships.
"Referrals can be great because you're not putting any marketing dollars into it, you're not putting a lot of time into it, but it requires having relationships with the right people," Stockton says.
Divorce attorneys, estate and probate attorneys, bankruptcy attorneys, property managers, real estate agents, and other investors all encounter distressed sellers regularly. The challenge is becoming the person they think of when those situations arise.
Stockton recommends joining your local Real Estate Investing Association (REIA) as a starting point. These groups exist specifically for networking, collaboration, and deal flow among investors. Relationships built there can generate warm introductions to professionals and direct referrals from other investors working deals outside their buy box.
Finding motivated sellers is about more than mastering individual marketing channels. It's also about building a repeatable system that generates consistent deal flow.
Investors who struggle tend to over-analyze before they ever reach out. They pull a list, then spend hours researching each property's comps, liens, and renovation potential before making a single call. Most of those owners will say no regardless.
"There's no point in spending an hour analyzing a property and putting together a potential offer if the lead is just going to say no once you reach out," Stockton adds.
The smarter approach: Build your list, run your marketing, and dig into property details only after you've connected with a seller who shows interest. You'll reach more leads in the same amount of time, and your analysis efforts go toward opportunities that might actually close.
Run this system consistently, and finding motivated sellers stops being a scramble. It becomes a machine you operate, one where every conversation starts with context about who you're talking to and why they might be ready to sell.
Ready to build your first list? Get PropPulse AI, advanced filtering, and verified contact data— start your PropertyReach trial today.